1. The Oyster Society – Seafood & Raw Bar
Upscale seafood and cocktails with live jazz. A stylish favorite with the island’s best oyster selection
2. Marco Prime Steaks & Seafood
Refined steakhouse in Marco Walk Plaza with premium steaks, lobster, and a top-tier wine list.
3. Snook Inn
Waterfront legend offering tropical drinks, live music, and sunset views.
4. Da Vinci’s Ristorante Italiano
Authentic Italian in a warm, family-friendly setting with fresh pasta and wood-fired pizza.
5. Cocomo’s Grill
Tiki-style casual dining with seafood, sushi, and macadamia-crusted fish.
6. 844 Gulf & Prime
Upscale steak & seafood newcomer with sleek interiors and dry-aged specialties.
7. Sand Bar
Local sports bar serving burgers, wings, and beer in a casual, laid-back space.
8. Davide Italian Café
Cozy chef-owned trattoria with handmade pastas and seafood linguine.
9. Doreen’s Cup of Joe
Creative breakfast and brunch menu with standout pancakes and benedicts.
10. Capri Fish House
Waterfront dining on Isle of Capri—casual, beachy, and perfect for stone crab season.
11. Nacho Mama’s Tex-Mex
Fun Mexican cantina with bold flavors, margaritas, and loaded nachos.
12. 2 Shea’s Salty Dog
Classic American bar food & drinks in a lively setting with an outdoor bar & patio & sports TV.
13. Dolphin Tiki Bar & Grill
Dockside dining with seafood baskets and tropical vibes.
14. La Mesa Taqueria & Bar
Stylish Mexican eatery with tacos, tequila, and elevated flavors.
15. La Tavola Restaurant & Bar
Creative American cuisine with live music, seasonal menus, and a lively piano bar vibe.
Plan Your Foodie Tour
Explore our Marco Island Restaurant Guide for menus, hours, reservations, and more.
One response to “Top 15 Restaurants in Marco Island (2025 Edition)”
[…] Want more options? Check out our Top 15 Restaurants in Marco Island 2025. […]